IEEE
You are not logged in, please sign in to edit > Log in / create account  

Thread history

From GHN

From Milestone-Proposal talk:The Abacus
Viewing a history listing
Jump to: navigation, search
descTime User Activity Comment
23:15, 7 March 2014Jbart64 (Talk | contribs)New reply created (Reply to Approval of the Proposal)
17:00, 18 February 2014Tbickart (Talk | contribs)New reply created (Reply to Approval of the Proposal)
21:24, 17 February 2014Feisel (Talk | contribs)New reply created (Reply to Approval of the Proposal)
21:43, 6 February 2014Kawamoto (Talk | contribs)New thread created 

As the Advocate of this proposal, I approve.

Hiro Kawamoto

Kawamoto21:43, 6 February 2014
 

I like the notion of recognizing the abacus as computing milestone. The date situation seems (quite understandably) to be a bit confused. I know I can't help determine an appropriate date but I hope some of our historians can get together and decide what an appropriate date might be. If a date is necessary at all.

I took the liberty of rearranging the citation a bit and show here both the original and the version I propose.

The abacus, which was already used in China by 570 C.E. the latest according to historical records, is the first calculating mechanism known to us. A typical abacus is constructed as a bamboo frame with beads sliding on rods. An abacus helps people keep the track of numbers as they calculate, and its invention was the first step towards to the design of automatic calculators.

The abacus was the first known calculating mechanism. According to historical records, it was used in China by at least 570 C.E.. A typical abacus is constructed as a bamboo frame with beads sliding on rods. An abacus helps people keep track of numbers as they calculate, and its invention was the first step toward the design of automatic calculators.

Just a suggestion.

Feisel21:24, 17 February 2014
 

I concur with Lyle's comments and much appreciate the further comments below on the history of the abacus as an IEEE Milestone Worthy achievement as we construct a trail--with numerous branches--of computing milestones. I have been struck by the trail of computing artifacts dating back many millennia that are on display in the Computer Museum in Mountain View, California (adjacent to San Jose). In particular, there are the counting rods also of millennia ago. (See https://www.google.com/#q=counting+sticks.)

Tbickart17:00, 18 February 2014
 

I like the idea of this milestone as an origin to computing. As I began to consider the wording, I read Feisel's suggestions which closely resemble where I was going to edit. I suggest adopting Feisel's recommended wording. --Dave Bart

Jbart6423:15, 7 March 2014