Special:Badtitle/NS90:Milestone-Proposal talk:Gapless Metal Oxide Surge Arrester (MOSA) for electric power systems,1975/my initial comments: Difference between revisions
(New thread: my initial comments) |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
This is a good proposal. | This is a good proposal. | ||
1. Pic (13) Please identify the name of the utility shown with the 500 kv MOS. There is no 'Canadian electric company'. | 1. Pic (13) Please identify the name of the utility shown with the 500 kv MOS. There is no 'Canadian electric company'. | ||
2. Transmission and distribution systems have always been safe and reliable. Please don't imply that world utilities were waiting for | 2. Transmission and distribution systems have always been safe and reliable. Please don't imply that world utilities were waiting for Meidensha's MOSA for safe and reliable power system operations. Guard wires, the double lines, redundant towers, the best available LA, safety codes, have been successfully applied by electrical engineers for over a century. There are real advantages to MOSA but without failure statistics, I cannot say at this moment. Perhaps MOSA for gas insulated apparatus can be separated from overhead transmission lines? | ||
3. Panasonic did license their zinc oxide varistors with leading world manufactures, eg. General Electric, ASEA and others. These enterprises were also involved with establishing international standards and raising performance levels. | 3. Panasonic did license their zinc oxide varistors with leading world manufactures, eg. General Electric, ASEA and others. These enterprises were also involved with establishing international standards and raising performance levels. | ||
Revision as of 17:43, 16 July 2013
This is a good proposal.
1. Pic (13) Please identify the name of the utility shown with the 500 kv MOS. There is no 'Canadian electric company'.
2. Transmission and distribution systems have always been safe and reliable. Please don't imply that world utilities were waiting for Meidensha's MOSA for safe and reliable power system operations. Guard wires, the double lines, redundant towers, the best available LA, safety codes, have been successfully applied by electrical engineers for over a century. There are real advantages to MOSA but without failure statistics, I cannot say at this moment. Perhaps MOSA for gas insulated apparatus can be separated from overhead transmission lines?
3. Panasonic did license their zinc oxide varistors with leading world manufactures, eg. General Electric, ASEA and others. These enterprises were also involved with establishing international standards and raising performance levels.
